Feeling or reason?

Have you been thinking lately about why you make the decisions you do?
Are they driven by reason or emotion? The world is constantly changing, becoming increasingly more instantaneous; information floods in through doors and windows. Or rather, through screens. We are exposed to thousands of commercial messages every day. We simply don’t have the capacity in our brains to rationally analyze this flood of information. We are increasingly making decisions based on intuition.

The pioneer of influencing literature, Robert Cialdini, lists six important tools for influencing other people. Reciprocity, authority, scarcity, consistency, consensus, and keeping (liking). The more we like someone, the better they are able to influence us. According to Cialdini, we like someone who:

  1. They are similar to me, share similar opinions, values, interests, and hobbies
  2. Share compliments
  3. Collaborates with us and shares similar goals
  4. He is beautiful, charming, handsome
  5. Associated with important and positive things to you


You prefer a nice guy rather than an unpleasant one, right? And even better, a salesperson who looks healthy and smells good, who smiles and maybe even offers a small compliment. And when you make the purchase, you find out that he or she also has the same hobby, like motorcycling. Yay, even better.

Let’s delve a little deeper into that first point, the similarity. You’ve probably noticed that motorcyclists wave to each other in traffic? The same goes for truck drivers and bus drivers. Sometimes Porsche drivers do this too. But Volkswagen drivers never do it. It’s a way of communicating belonging to the same tribe, and of course, passion. Volkswagen drivers are less likely to have a passionate relationship with driving, especially with the Volkswagen they drive. Hobbies are often approached with passion. Therefore, if you want the ground to be more conducive, for example in important contract negotiations, it may be wise to find out about the hobbies of the other party and try to find a common topic of discussion from the world of that hobby.

The signatory's completely illogical decision

I’ll share my personal experience. We rent our cottage through Airbnb when we don’t use it ourselves. Over the years, my wife and I have made the decision that we will not rent the cottage to groups of friends. I’ve built the cottage with the idea that the children will enjoy it for as long as possible as they grow older. The cottage has plenty of activities and can accommodate a larger group of people. So it’s the perfect destination for families with children. But also for groups of friends looking for a cottage for a wet weekend getaway.

After visits by groups of friends, the place has been in such a state a few times that the decision to rent it to families was easy. Trash bags strewn around, the fridge glass shelf broken and glass shards everywhere, trash cans scattered around, empty bottles and cans in the strangest places, broken furniture, etc.

But a wave of anxiety came over me when, despite a clear line of division, I decided to rent a cottage to a group of students. It was the final meeting of the board of the Vaasa University of Applied Sciences ski club. It was said that there would be a relaxed evening among the board members, with talking and grilling. I myself studied at the university of applied sciences and was also involved in various events of the Helsinki University of Applied Sciences ski club KY-Ski. Although I remembered that these events were quite wet and muddy, I still decided to rent the cottage. I discussed it with the landlord and he seemed like a really nice and responsible person. And they weren’t coming to the cottage with more than 10 people. I guess the students already know how to behave these days. After all, there was Covid19, social distancing was kept, etc.

How wrong I was. The neighbor told me that both weekends mornings they managed to fall asleep around 5 a.m. The terrible mess had filled the yard. My friend who lives a couple of kilometers away on the opposite bank also told me that he had been wondering about the hellish situation. It also turned out that there weren’t 10 but 15 guests. Moreover, on Saturday, it was also reported that a couple of boats had parked on the shore. I don’t know how many of them stayed overnight. I returned 320 empty bottles, plus some wine and wine bottles.

On Sunday while tidying up, I was wondering why on earth I had rented a cottage to that group of students. I had to explain my stupid decision to my wife again. It is, however, a basic fact that during my long marriage I have often found myself in a similar situation. I didn’t really understand at the time what the miracle had been. Until it happened. Cialdini’s keeping the like button was a big factor. If the cottage had been for rent by the ski club of a certain age, I wouldn’t have rented it. This time it was a group of people from the store and also members of the local ski club. In other words, they were members of the same clan as myself. It has to be a good clan. It might be a good clan, but from a neighborly point of view it is very questionable. The ski club wasn’t really changed at all in a single generation. Apparently the ski club of the store still holds the same wet and noisy routine today.

Now comes a tip. If you want to rent a cabin and your morale lets you give in a little to the manipulation, do a Google search on the owner of the cabin and find common interests. Communicate these to the owner and you might be surprised. Perhaps the rules of the cabin are no longer quite right and you might get unexpected benefits. If there is a tendency to wear a turtleneck, you could imagine the following scenario. The store has just had a course on influencing people and they googled the signed agreement. You don’t have to be a very good detective to find out that the student place is available and that skiing is close to my heart. ”We found a suitable cabin but the listing says no for groups of friends, only families. But I Googled and it turns out that the friend has also studied at the store and does skiing. Don’t worry, I’ll take us there; we just had a lecture on influencing people at the sales course. I’m in the secret club to talk us through it!”

What then?

From the perspective of similarity, the principle of influencing is something worth considering in various situations in life. How are we influenced? All of life is about influencing, and various negotiation situations come up every day. On the other hand, we must be careful not to let influencing lead us down the path of manipulation, which is simply wrong. That is the wrong use of influencing. But at its best, the tools of influencing are perfect vehicles for getting the message across. In marketing, for example, and at events, we strive to influence the thinking of the target audience; we light up the target audience’s minds, and that hopefully leads to concrete actions. We are thinking about these things at Pulp. How can we get the desired message as effectively as possible, both at btob and btoc events?

Leave a message kari.haapalainen@pulp.fi if you want to hear more.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn